ResellMargin

Comparison

eBay vs Etsy Fees: Which Is Cheaper to Sell On in 2026?

10 min read

Say you come home from an estate sale with a 1970s Pyrex bowl set, a pair of barely worn Nike Dunks and a box of brand-new craft punches still in the packaging. Before you think about eBay vs Etsy fees, ask a blunter question: which of those items is Etsy even willing to host? Two of the three qualify. The sneakers don't. That single rule decides more than any fee table, but once an item is eligible for both, the fee gap is real and worth knowing to the dollar.

Fees verified against eBay's official United States fee pages on 16 November 2026. Checked daily for changes (fee change tracker). Source: eBay eBay.com fee page.

The short verdict

On a plain sale with no ads, Etsy is cheaper. Its core fees (a listing fee, a transaction fee and payment processing) land around 9.5% plus small fixed charges, while eBay.com takes 13.6% on most categories plus a per-order fee, with no separate payment processing fee.

That headline flips in three situations: an Etsy sale that comes through an Offsite Ad, an eBay category with a low rate (guitars, computers with a store, heavy equipment), and selling as a private seller in markets like the UK or Germany where eBay charges nothing. And for most resellers the question is moot, because typical eBay inventory isn't allowed on Etsy at all.

eBay vs Etsy fees side by side

eBay figures below come from our verified eBay.com fee data. Etsy figures are from Etsy's published US Fees & Payments Policy; Etsy is not part of our live fee feed, so check Etsy's policy page if you're reading this long after publication.

FeeeBay.comEtsy (US)
Listing / insertionMonthly free-listing allowance; small insertion fee only beyond it$0.20 per listing, renews every 4 months and each time an item sells
Final value / transaction fee13.6% on most categories, plus $0.30–$0.40 per order6.5% of item price plus shipping
Payment processingNone (built into the final value fee)3% + $0.25 per order, on the total including tax
AdsPromoted Listings, optional, ad rate you setEtsy Ads optional; Offsite Ads 15% (optional) or 12% (mandatory above $10,000 a year), capped at $100 per order
Store / subscriptionOptional Store tiers; Basic and up unlock lower category ratesEtsy Plus optional at $10/month; no rate discount
Fees on shipping charged to buyerYesYes
Fees on sales taxYes, final value fee includes taxProcessing fee only; transaction fee excludes tax

The 13.6% figure is the default. eBay sets different rates by category, and some categories (jewelry, handbags, sneakers) apply a threshold to the whole sale rather than a slice of it:

CategoryNo storeBasic store or higher
Most categories13.6% up to $7,500, 2.35% on the rest12.7% up to $2,500, 2.35% on the rest
Women's bags & handbags15% if the sale is up to $2,000; 9% above $2,00013% if the sale is up to $2,000; 7% above $2,000
Jewelry (except watches)15% if the sale is up to $5,000; 9% above $5,00013% if the sale is up to $5,000; 7% above $5,000
Books, movies & music15.3% up to $7,500, 2.35% on the rest15.3% up to $2,500, 2.35% on the rest
Laptops, desktops, tablets & game consoles13.6% up to $7,500, 2.35% on the rest7.35% up to $2,500, 2.35% on the rest
Guitars & basses6.7% up to $7,500, 2.35% on the rest6.7% up to $2,500, 2.35% on the rest

Handmade marketplace fees only matter if Etsy takes your stock

Etsy is a handmade marketplace with two exceptions. Everything you list has to fit one of three buckets:

Run a typical reseller bin through those rules and most of it fails. Modern thrifted clothing, retail arbitrage, returns pallets, current-gen electronics, recent sneakers, new-in-box toys and mainstream video games are all out. Etsy does remove listings and suspend shops for reselling items that don't qualify, so "list it and see" is a bad plan.

What does qualify is narrower but valuable: genuine vintage clothing and housewares, older costume jewelry, mid-century decor, vintage paper and ephemera, and sewing, beading or scrapbooking supplies. If that describes a meaningful share of your inventory, the comparison below is worth your time. If it doesn't, your real choice is between eBay and the resale apps, which we cover in eBay vs Mercari vs Poshmark take-home per $100 sale.

The same sale worked through on both platforms

Three hypothetical sales, each with shipping charged to the buyer, all in eBay's default category on eBay.com with no store, no promotion and a seller in good standing. Etsy figures include the listing fee, transaction fee and payment processing. Sales tax is left out here and handled in its own section below.

Example: $25 vintage Pyrex bowl + $5 shipping = $30.00 paid by the buyer

  • eBay fees: $4.48 (14.9%), take-home $25.52
  • Etsy fees, no Offsite Ad: $3.30 (11.0%), take-home $26.70
  • Etsy fees with a 12% Offsite Ad: $6.90 (23.0%)
  • Etsy fees with a 15% Offsite Ad: $7.80 (26.0%)

Example: $100 vintage leather jacket + $10 shipping = $110.00 paid by the buyer

  • eBay fees: $15.36 (14.0%), take-home $94.64
  • Etsy fees, no Offsite Ad: $10.90 (9.9%), take-home $99.10
  • Etsy fees with a 12% Offsite Ad: $24.10 (21.9%)
  • Etsy fees with a 15% Offsite Ad: $27.40 (24.9%)

Example: $500 mid-century lamp + $20 shipping = $520.00 paid by the buyer

  • eBay fees: $71.12 (13.7%), take-home $448.88
  • Etsy fees, no Offsite Ad: $49.85 (9.6%), take-home $470.15
  • Etsy fees with a 12% Offsite Ad: $112.25 (21.6%)
  • Etsy fees with a 15% Offsite Ad: $127.85 (24.6%)

On the $100 sale, Etsy keeps $4.46 more in your pocket than eBay when no ad is involved. But one Offsite Ad sale wipes that out and then some: you'd pay $12.04 more than eBay at the 15% rate. The pattern holds at every price point until the $100 cap kicks in on very expensive orders.

Your own numbers will differ by category, shipping charge and promotion. Plug a real price into the eBay profit calculator and set it beside the Etsy math above.

When the answer flips

Etsy Offsite Ads

Etsy advertises your listings on Google, social media and partner sites. When a buyer clicks one of those ads and buys within 30 days, Etsy charges an Offsite Ads fee on the order total (item plus shipping, not tax). Shops under $10,000 in sales over the past 12 months pay 15% and can opt out. Once a shop crosses that line, participation becomes mandatory at 12%, and it stays mandatory. Either way the fee is capped at $100 per order.

Rule of thumb: if you can still opt out of Etsy Offsite Ads, do the math before you leave them on. A single attributed sale turns Etsy from the cheaper platform into the more expensive one, and you have no control over which sales get attributed.

eBay categories with low (or high) rates

Category choice swings eBay's side of the ledger hard. A $520.00 vintage guitar sale costs $35.24 on eBay with no store (6.8%), which beats Etsy's $49.85 even before an Offsite Ad. In the other direction, a $110.00 vintage jewelry sale on eBay costs $16.90 (15.4%), and a $30.00 book costs $4.99 (16.6%). Vintage jewelry and old books are where Etsy's lead is widest.

Don't ignore eBay's per-order fee on cheap items either. At $0.30 on small orders and $0.40 above the threshold, it adds proportionally more to a low-priced sale, though Etsy's own fixed charges ($0.20 listing plus $0.25 processing) are just as heavy at the bottom end.

eBay Store plans for high-value items

Basic and higher Store tiers switch you to a lower category table. The effect is modest in most categories but large in a few. A $520.00 vintage computer or console sale on a Basic store costs $38.62 (7.4%), clearly under Etsy. Whether the monthly fee pays for itself depends on volume; our eBay Store subscription breakeven guide works through each tier.

PlanMonthly feeFree listingsEffect on final value fee
No store—Unlimited—
Starter$4.95 ($7.95 monthly renewal)250None (listing benefits only)
Basic$21.95 ($27.95 monthly renewal)1,000Lower category rates
Premium$59.95 ($74.95 monthly renewal)10,000Lower category rates
Anchor$299.95 ($349.95 monthly renewal)25,000Lower category rates
Enterprise$2,999.95100,000Lower category rates

eBay Promoted Listings

eBay's answer to paid visibility is Promoted Listings, where you choose the ad rate. Promote that $100 jacket at a hypothetical 5% and you add about $5.50, bringing eBay to $20.86, still below Etsy with a 15% Offsite Ad. The key difference: on eBay you choose whether to promote and at what rate. On a larger Etsy shop, you don't.

Private sellers in the UK and Germany

US eBay uses one schedule for everyone, but several European eBay sites split private and business sellers. Private sellers in the UK pay no final value fee, and private sellers in Germany pay nothing on sales within Germany. A private seller clearing out genuine vintage in those markets has no fee reason to choose Etsy at all. Business sellers there pay category-based rates instead; our eBay fees by country ranking shows how each market compares.

Costs most comparisons miss

Fees on sales tax and shipping

Both platforms charge on the shipping you collect from the buyer, so a cheap item with high shipping isn't a fee loophole anywhere. Sales tax is where they differ. eBay's final value fee is calculated on the total including tax, while Etsy only applies its payment processing fee to the tax portion. With a hypothetical 8% sales tax on the $110.00 order, tax adds $1.20 to your eBay fees but only $0.26 on Etsy. Small, but it widens Etsy's lead in high-tax states.

Shipping labels

Both sell discounted carrier labels and deduct them from your balance. Label prices aren't a fee in the strict sense, but compare them for your usual package sizes before assuming the shipping charge you set covers the label on both.

Payout timing and reserves

eBay pays out daily or weekly once your account is established, with holds on newer accounts. Etsy lets you pick a deposit schedule, but it can place a reserve that holds back part of your balance, often on new shops or after a spike in cases. Neither costs a percentage, yet a reserve on Etsy can tie up cash you planned to spend on inventory.

Refunds and cancellations

On eBay, a refund credits the variable part of the final value fee; don't count on getting the fixed per-order fee back. On Etsy, the transaction fee is credited on refunds, but the payment processing fee and the listing fee are not returned. A returned item costs you something on both platforms.

Currency conversion and international buyers

Etsy charges 2.5% when your listing currency differs from your payment account currency. eBay applies its own currency conversion charge when payouts are converted, and adds a 1.65% international fee when a US seller sells to a buyer abroad, waived if you ship through eBay International Shipping. For a fuller breakdown see how eBay payments and payouts work now.

Why other sites give conflicting answers

Search this question and you'll find pages that disagree by several percentage points. The usual causes:

Selling on both: what goes where

The smart setup for a reseller with some vintage stock is not either-or. Keep everything on eBay, and add only Etsy-eligible items to an Etsy shop.

Beyond fees: audience and buyer expectations

eBay's buyer base is broader and more search-driven; people arrive looking for a specific item, model or part, and auctions still work for rare pieces. Etsy buyers browse for style, gifts and one-off finds, and they expect strong photos, descriptive titles and a shop that feels curated.

Frequently asked questions

Is Etsy or eBay cheaper to sell on, and how much does each take from a $100 sale?

Etsy is cheaper on a sale with no Offsite Ad. On a $100 item with $10 shipping, Etsy takes about $10.90 and eBay takes $15.36 in its default category. If that Etsy sale came through an Offsite Ad, Etsy takes $24.10 to $27.40, well above eBay. Both charge on shipping; eBay also charges its full rate on sales tax, while Etsy only charges processing on it.

Can eBay resellers sell their items on Etsy?

Only if the items are handmade by you, at least 20 years old, or craft supplies. Most modern resale inventory, including thrifted current clothing, sneakers, electronics and retail arbitrage, isn't allowed and can get a shop suspended.

Are Etsy Offsite Ads fees mandatory, and do either charge monthly fees?

Offsite Ads are optional at 15% until your shop makes $10,000 in a 12-month period; after that they're mandatory at 12%. Neither platform requires a monthly fee: eBay Stores and Etsy Plus are optional, and only eBay's Basic and higher Store tiers lower your selling rates.

Related guides

eBay fee calculators for other markets

Selling internationally? Check the 2026 fee breakdown for any of the other eBay markets we cover — each page has the same profit, ROI and margin tools tailored to local rates.